Where the Wild Things Are Review [2]
Posted by Shawn S. Lealos on 10.20.2009
It's not the next great kid's flick, but it is a masterpiece.
Directed by Spike Jonze
Written by Spike Jonze and Dave Eggers
Cast
Max Records ... Max
Pepita Emmerichs ... Claire
Catherine Keener ... Mom
Steve Mouzakis ... Teacher
Mark Ruffalo ... The Boyfriend
James Gandolfini ... Carol (voice)
Paul Dano ... Alexander (voice)
Catherine O'Hara ... Judith (voice)
Forest Whitaker ... Ira (voice)
Michael Berry Jr. ... The Bull (voice)
Chris Cooper ... Douglas (voice)
Lauren Ambrose ... KW (voice)
Where the Wild Things Are is not what you might expect.
First and foremost, it is not a children’s movie. This movie, in no way, talks to kids. It is instead made for adults who remember what it was like to, at one time, be a child. Do you remember how hard it was to be a kid, to be considered trouble and never understand what your parent’s expected from you? More than likely, you are an adult who doesn’t actually remember these feelings. Where the Wild Things Are will help you remember what it was like to be at one of the most difficult ages to understand.
Max is a young boy whose mother is having a lot of problems at work. His sister is growing up and hanging out with the older boys instead of her kid brother. He also seems to have no friends and his father is missing in action. None of his life is explained beyond this because the genius of the movie is it plays from Max’s point of view. Most movies about kids see them in an omnipresent sort of way, either watching them as they go about their business or, worse yet, looking at them from the adult’s point of view. These movies show kids experiencing exciting situations but none let you know what it is like to be the child. Spike Jonze allows us to see his movie through those eyes and it is a wondrous thing.
Another problem you might have going into this movie is expecting the film to be like all other magical children’s films and tell you the story, morals spelled out and lessons clearly learned. Where the Wild Things Are expects you to use your brain, understand the lessons as Max understands them and then at the end, figure out what it is you are supposed to have learned. Spike Jonze is not making this movie for brain dead Americans to have their lessons spelled out to them in a giant moralistic tale. He has always worked as an intelligent storyteller. His previous films, Being John Malkovich and Adaptation, confused the hell out of mainstream audiences because they “didn’t get it.” This movie will do the exact same thing. I have already heard people question the end and complain the movie has no point. These people are incapable, or unwilling, to read the film for what it is.
We don’t know where Max’s father is because he is at the age where he might still harbor confusion of where he went. We don’t know what his mother’s occupational problems are but know that Max is able to help make his mother smile when she is down. Max wants to play with his sister’s older friends but when they get a little too rough, he is left hurt and crying and throws a tantrum. We understand he is unable to fit in anywhere in his world. When he acts up and gets in trouble, he runs away from home and finds a raft which he uses to travel to the land of the Wild Things.
It is here Max finds a Wild Thing named Carol who he identifies with. A giant loveable beast who destroys things when he feels overwhelmed or unloved. Max sees a kindred spirit and in Max he sees himself. But then Max, and we join him for this journey, watches as everything he does seems to make things worse. We see everything he went through at home play out in this land of giant creatures. He sees his actions have a definite effect on those around him and finally realizes that, despite his preoccupation with his own small life, there is much more to the world than his problems. Once he understands that, he can move on and start to help others and find there are people willing to help him as well.
This is a lot to take in for a movie that advertises giant beasts playing in a strange land with a child who proclaims to be their king. That is why Spike Jonze has created a masterpiece. It is a movie that will be misunderstood by millions of people but is also a movie that will bring millions more to tears. There is a lot in this movie to take in, and it may take numerous viewings to capture all Jonze has created for us to see. This is the story of a young boy who has reached the age where it is time to take the next step and grow into a young man. He has to hurdle a few obstacles along the way, and he will lose a lot in doing so, but at the end of the movie he is a different person, a child with the understanding of what his actions is doing to those he loves. When he tells the Wild Things he wishes they “had a mother”, you know he finally understands what he has and what he turned his back on.
Max Records is a marvel as young Max. I have not seen a strong performance from a child actor like this in a long, long time. He has the talent of a Dakota Fanning or Freddie Highmore and takes his character into areas so dark and so varied and never once faltered. The emotion he shows in his face is amazing for someone his age (Max is 12). The Wild Things are all voiced by great actors who bring their characters into life in ways I never expected. James Gandolfini is fantastic conveying the confusion of Carol. Paul Dano, Catherine O’Hara, Forest Whitaker, Michael Berry Jr, Chris Cooper and Lauren Abbrose round out the Wild Things and I can’t think of anything that could have been done better than what these voice talents achieved.
Spike Jonze creates one of the most aesthetically beautiful pictures I have ever seen. This is a movie I am already excited to re-watch on Blu-Ray. Once Max gets to the Wild Things island, the scenery and cinematography are some of the most beautiful I have ever seen. If this movie doesn’t receive any other awards, the cinematography is the one it deserves most. From desert landscapes to forests surrounded by trees to underground layers, Spike Jonze creates a world breathtaking every step of the way. He has created his masterpiece.
The 411: Where the Wild Things Are is not an easy film to sit through. It is the most Indie looking kid’s flick you might ever see. The camera work is handheld, the script forces the viewer to read between the lines and the story is not meant for children but instead for the child within. But if you are a more discerning viewer, this movie has much to offer. The look of the movie is gorgeous and Spike Jonze has created a picture that is a beauty to behold. The story is complicated, deep and very effecting for those who actually understand what Jonze is saying. It is a movie about growing up, facing your fears and doubts, and coming out on the other side, no longer a Wild Thing. The acting is superb and the movie will reward repeated viewings. This movie is not for everyone but, for those it does connect with, it is one of the best films you might ever see.
saw it, it wasnt a masterpiece, it was a great movie with flaws
8/10
Posted By: marc (Guest) on October 20, 2009 at 12:32 AM
Try desensitizing your wussy kids a little then... that's all I can really say. or else they will grow up overly coddled like all the other kids born after 1990...
Posted By: M:-X (Guest) on October 20, 2009 at 11:04 AM
I am upset at Warner Bros. mireprentation of this film as it is not for kids and family. No child should see this depressing, fearful, violent, morose interptation of a fun kids book. Warner saw they had 80 million dollar problem that the this filmkids book was not made for kids. This is childrens films is huge market still., Yet they have put out this awesome marketing and pump as a great family film. It is criminal misrepresentation of the film as seen by me leaving with my crying 3 year old and 7 out of the theater. It is scary how almost all the reviews do not warn of disturbing its nature for kids. The film is beautifully done, but German Cinema is more uplifting.
Posted By: cybernaut (Guest) on October 20, 2009 at 07:27 AM
I am upset at Warner Bros. mireprentation of this film as it is not for kids and family. No child should see this depressing, fearful, violent, morose interptation of a fun kids book. Warner saw they had 80 million dollar problem that the this filmkids book was not made for kids. This is childrens films is huge market still., Yet they have put out this awesome marketing and pump as a great family film. It is criminal misrepresentation of the film as seen by me leaving with my crying 3 year old and 7 out of the theater. It is scary how almost all the reviews do not warn of disturbing its nature for kids. The film is beautifully done, but German Cinema is more uplifting.
Posted By: cybernaut (Guest) on October 20, 2009 at 07:27 AM
I don't remember the trailers or tv spots saying the tired old lines of "the best family film of the year" or "the kids will love it"......ya know, sometimes it's depressing being a child in a broken home and not feeling like anyone listens to you....that's the whole point......and violent?? are you shitting me?? DISNEY movies are more violent than that! I didn't walk away from Lion King thinking they world was a terrible place because Mufasa died....lighten up!! It's an amazing film and was never brandished as a "family" film just because it's an old childrens book
Posted By: Erik (Guest) on October 20, 2009 at 11:45 AM
Of course some uptight, jerk has to come along and bitch about raping my childhood, and how the movie is inappropriate for their kids. A dumb ass in this article from CNN claims her 20 month old was "bored" .... of course they were you idiot.
A 20 month old child would be bored watching anything were you had to remain seated and quiet for an extended period. Hell they would get bored watching a circus, where elephants shot fire out of their trunks setting dancing and juggling clowns on fire. While the lion tamer gets eaten and the trained poodles go have a 20 dog gang bang. If it lasted longer than 5 minutes. I'm 34 and I get bored watching movies sometimes.
The short 10 sentence book may have been intended for a toddler, but the feature length move is targeted toward older kids and adults who have fond memories of the book from their childhood.
Posted By: baker (Guest) on October 20, 2009 at 09:22 AM
Thank you thank you for someone addressing the fact that this movie is marketed towards the beloved childhood memory we all have of this WONDERFUL book. It was a violent, depressing, dark, and gloomy depiction of a literary master piece. I actually felt GUILTY for taking my 5 year old to the movie, and he was in a funk the rest of the weekend. I don't even want to read the book anymore because of the now dark feeling I equate with it. I wanted to do something so fun with my son and he was so sad that everyone was yelling at each other and speaking so cruelly to Max and the rest of the monsters. I realize you do say that this is for children, but how about addressing the fact that it's based on a kids' book, marketed as being a family movie, and has a trailer put together to advertise the book we all loved growing up that the whole family will enjoy. HORRIBLE. If I were Sendak I would be sick.
Posted By: Jill (Guest) on October 20, 2009 at 09:50 AM
I personally feel bad for anyone that doesn't truly understand the deep meaning of the film. It was a magical movie and all of the Wild Things had their own personalities...the best part of their characters were that they were all a part of Max's traits:
Carol-Anger and fear
KW-Love
Ira-Innocence
Douglas-Helpful and kind
Judith-Doubt and frustration
Alexander-Loneliness and exclusion
The Bull-Quiet and content
These all represent Max and we see them at war with each other when things aren't going they way they expected them to...that's the point!! Max is a confused little boy thrust into many situations of his life he doesn't know how to control, and all of these different traits and emotions clash....that's why he has to let go of Carol (his anger)...he has to grow up!
That's why this film is phenomenal! It's a great story, with great visuals and a great underlying theme...I hope everyone can take the time to truly see these things.
Posted By: Erik (Guest) on October 20, 2009 at 11:50 AM
Why did you bring your kids to this anyway? Even as a child the story was never just about children. This movie was a delightful treat for adults that remember being children or have had children.
Posted By: Kelly (Guest) on October 20, 2009 at 01:07 PM
Screw those who say this movie isn't for kids. I would much rather show a child this than some Disney princess movie that builds in kids the false and insulting idea that some day a "prince" is going to swoop in and "save" them.
Posted By: Guest#4516 (Guest) on October 20, 2009 at 07:59 PM
Violent? Why, because some trees got knocked over? Give me a fucking break. Erik makes a great point. The central plot point of The Lion King is MURDER! Some of the older Disney films can be scary as fuck for kids, but because it's DISNEY (Disnazi, as it should be called), everything they ever put out is "a classic family film," or whatever garbage they spew at you. Give me a break. Wild Things was amazing, and if your kid didn't like it, big deal. Does your kid like every movie they ever watch?
Posted By: Talon (Guest) on October 21, 2009 at 12:26 PM
Holy fuck, the movie was not good. Like... ahhh! It was so God damn pretentious and left absolutely nothing with me. All of the wild things being part of Max's personality is fine, but there was absolutely nothing I liked about his character or the wild things. Like... a 4/10 maybe. It just was not a good movie.
Posted By: Jeremy (Guest) on October 21, 2009 at 07:19 PM
"...HORRIBLE. If I were Sendak I would be sick."
Posted By: Jill (Guest) on October 20, 2009 at 09:50 AM
Well it's a good thing that you're not, and that he is, because he said himself in the extended trailer that he loves the movie and thinks it is in the spirit of his book. See? Now you're not only wrong, but you're besmirched too. Double points for me.
Posted By: James (Registered) (Guest) on October 22, 2009 at 02:48 AM
I like how everyone is claiming the book is "WONDERFUL" and fun and innocent and what not. Have you people actually read the book? The book about about who dresses like a Wolf, causes a bunch of damage in his house, escapes to an island with monsters that cause destruction and want to eat him?
Posted By: Dave C (Guest) on October 23, 2009 at 09:00 AM
Holy fucking ass fuck.
No one cares about how your kids got bored of the movie fucking 10 minutes in.
Really, no one does.
If you honestly expect a kid to sit through a movie that isn't fucking Pixar or Disney for longer than 20 god damn minutes then you're insane.
Flat out insane.
While I have to agree that it is dumb that it was advertised as a family movie.
But I want you to think about that.
Family.
Not just your stupid ass 20 month old son. Who, would get bored of just about anything you could think of, but the entire. God. Damn. Family.
It was a beautiful movie. Just shut the fuck up and accept it.
Posted By: Mike (Guest) on October 24, 2009 at 05:47 AM
There were things about this movie I liked, and things I didn't. I walked out being very confused about how I felt about it.
The main problem is that it can't decide what kind of movie it wants to be, and every really creative idea it attempts, it forgets about it as quickly as it is suggested.
Basically this movie is all over the place. It's part kids movie, part inner-child movie aimed towards adults, part imagination-come-to-life, part science fiction/fantasy, part plotless psychedelic tripfest, but isn't completely any of these things. The ending is incredibly non-satisfactory, and the emotional reactions of the wild things seem forced and without reason. Also this is not a feel-good movie by any stretch of the imagination.
On the positive side, the soundtrack guides the feel of the movie well, the acting is all good to great, the cinematography and visual effects are amazing, and it captured the feel of the book quite well. Other than those positives, I don't find much reason to watch this film again.
I give Where the Wild Things Are a 7/10 for adults who want to feel nostalgic, a 6/10 as a kids movie (mostly based on the huge depression factor), and a 4/10 as a plot based fantasy movie.
Posted By: James (Registered) (Guest) on October 30, 2009 at 11:51 PM