www.411mania.com
|  News |  Album Reviews |  Columns |  News Report |  Hall Of Fame |
SPOTLIGHTS  SPOTLIGHTS
MOVIES/TV
// Top 5 Worst Star Wars Characters
MUSIC
// Top 10 Grammy Album of the Year Winners
WRESTLING
// Trish Stratus Thong Pics
POLITICS
// Rick Santorum Surging In National Poll
MMA
// Nick Diaz Tests Positive for Marijuana Metabolites
GAMES
// Modern Warfare 3 Retains Top Spot in January NPD


CD REVIEWS  CD REVIEWS
//  Hospitality - Hospitality Review
//  Sharon Van Etten - Tramp Review
//  Air - La Voyage Dans Le Lune Review
//  Imperial Teen - Feel The Sound Review
//  Seal - Soul 2 Review
//  Craig Finn - Clear Heart Full Eyes Review
 HOT ARTISTS
//  Kanye West
//  Lil Wayne
//  Rihanna
//  Britney Spears
//  Lady GaGa
SYNDICATE  SYNDICATE



411mania RSS Feeds





Follow 411mania on Twitter!




Add 411 On Facebook
 



 
 411mania » Music » Album Reviews



Advertisement
Slash - Slash Review
Posted by Aaron Titan on 04.06.2010






The Tracklisting

01) “Ghost” featuring Ian Astbury of The Cult & Izzy Stradlin (ex-Guns N’ Roses)
02) “Crucify the Dead” featuring Ozzy Osbourne and Taylor Hawkins of Foo Fighters/Taylor Hawkins and the Coattail Riders
03) “Beautiful Dangerous” featuring Fergie
04) “Back from Cali” featuring Myles Kennedy of Alter Bridge
05) “Promise” featuring Chris Cornell of Soundgarden/ex-Audioslave
06) “By the Sword” featuring Andrew Stockdale of Wolfmother
07) “Gotten” featuring Adam Levine of Maroon 5
08) “Doctor Alibi” featuring Lemmy Kilmeister of Motorhead
09) “Watch This” featuring Dave Grohl (Foo Fighters/Them Crooked Vultures/ex-Nirvana) and Duff McKagan (Velvet Revolver/Duff McKagan’s Loaded/Jane’s Addiction/ex-Guns N’ Roses)
10) “I Hold On” featuring Kid Rock
11) “Nothing to Say” featuring M. Shadows of Avenged Sevenfold
12) “Starlight” featuring Myles Kennedy of Alter Bridge
13) “Saint is a Sinner Too” featuring Rocco DeLuca of Rocco DeLuca and The Burden
14) “We’re All Gonna Die” featuring Iggy Pop











The Album

Just to preface before I begin here, I’m only going to be reviewing the Standard Edition that’s being released here in the U.S. (and most of the globe from what I gathered on Wikipedia). There are other versions with other tracks on them that feature other artists you’ve heard of, such as Alice Cooper and Flea. You can actually peep out this album via AOL Music just like I did. Not sure how long this will stay up on that site, but I figure it’ll be there until release day and a few days afterwards.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

OK, so I just got done listening to Slash’s solo album from start to finish. I’ve been reading and reporting about this thing for several months now (via my column here on 411Mania: The Music 3R’s) and it’s finally arrived. Most of you know the story behind the album here, but if not, essentially, Slash decided he wanted to have some fun and make a solo album.

Velvet Revolver has been stagnant for a really long time now, ever since the departure of vocalist Scott Wieland in 2008. Slash and company haven’t been able to find a proper vocalist to fill this vacancy despite their endless auditioning process. So now, he’s got the time to do this solo project he mentioned in his autobiography (read that shit if you haven’t yet!).

From what I read about this album, Slash wrote a bunch of music and guitar riffs and shopped them around to potential collaborators he thought would sound well on each track. If the artist bit, he brought them into the studio and they arranged and recorded the song. Think Santana’s Supernatural album, but like, heavier and without Rob Thomas.

The result itself was incredibly underwhelming considering the parties involved. On paper, this album looks pretty bitchin’ overall, doesn’t it? I can honestly say that I was pumped after seeing the tracklisting and who was on each song. I’ve been a Gn’R fan since forever, dug Velvet Revolver’s first album, and like many of the artists Slash got on board for this project; however, overall, it just doesn’t cut the mustard.

I mean, you’ve got Slash and Ozzy doing a song together, which is cool and all, but it would’ve meant much more like, at least ten years ago when Ozzy hadn’t lost all the cred and respect he had left. The bigness of this collaboration just wasn’t there for me and “Crucify the Dead” is just mediocre at best.

The Fergie song “Beautiful Dangerous” sounds passable from a musical perspective. Slash’s riffing isn’t the problem at all. It’s just that you’ve got Fergie on there trying to be something she’s not: a rock singer. She’s a hip-hop Wack-Ass Peas singer and she’s going out of her way on this song to put some rock n’ roll grit on her voice like she’s Lita Ford or something. It just doesn’t work and comes off pretty annoying, though I can see a lot of fans liking this song for whatever reason.

And fuck man, not that Kid Rock is that great of a vocalist to begin with, but how did Slash and his sound engineer sit there and master this album and not recognize that “I Hold On” has the worst sounding vocals on the entire album? It’s really weak and gaspy at times and Kid Rock was capable of much more than that.

Also, you’ve got a lot of mediocrity on here in places you wouldn’t expect it. The Chris Cornell and Adam Levine tracks, “Promise” and “Gotten” respectively, while cool and interesting collaborations in theory, just don’t work and end up sounding like anything else on rock radio, which is where this album will undoubtedly find some decent success.

What did bum me out was that M. Shadows of Avenged Sevenfold didn’t come in and kill it on a track like I thought he would. “Nothing to Say” ends up sounding like a B-side AX7 wannabe of a song in the end in every sense possible. I mean, I could see where you could make an argument that Synyster Gates, the lead guitarist of AX7, takes a lot of cues from Slash’s iconic playing and sound, but on this track I just felt like Slash was trying to play like Gates to accompany Shadows’ singing, which isn’t necessary or even desirable on YOUR OWN SOLO ALBUM. I figured these two would be a killer pairing but it just wasn’t meant to be.

Thankfully, it’s not all just a basket of throwaways! The riff and vocals of the Ian Astbury- and Izzy Stradlin-feature track, “Ghost,” are pretty saucy and fun. “By the Sword,” the lead single off of the album, is in good graces with me too. It’s catchy and Andrew Stockdale of the mighty Wolfmother hasn’t been able to do wrong by this writer as of yet. “Watch This” is a fun instrumental jam that features Dave Grohl on drums and Jane’s Addiction’s new bass player Duff McKagan on…well, the bass obviously. I could see this song being a key staple of Slash’s solo band’s set when he takes these tunes out on the road this year.

The standout track for me is “Doctor Alibi” which features the godliness of Motorhead’s Lemmy Kilmeister. It’s just a fuckin’ awesome, simple punked-up metal song that makes the rest of the corny poppiness that pervades the majority of the disc sound silly.

In the end though, I just don’t get a “Slash experience.” Nothing about this album really makes me respect Slash anymore than I did, and I’ll go as far as saying I respect him a little less now. He’s trying to do too many styles here to accompany the myriad of guest spots rather than having those artists instead, adapt to a Slash album and make the whole affair more interesting and unique in that respect.


The 411: While there are a few decent tracks on the album, there's more 'meh' and way more garbage to make the disc salvageable. It's not that there's too much going on style-wise, but it just lacks any sense of the 'WOW' factor that Slash's playing had on past albums he's been a part of. Myles Kennedy should've just joined Velvet Revolver, since his two songs sound pretty decent and he's going to be Slash's touring vocalist anyways. All in all, the album looks good on paper, but unfortunately, we don't have paper in our ears.
 
Final Score:  5.5   [ Not So Good ]  legend


Post Comment (18)  |  Email Aaron Titan  |  View Aaron Titan's 411 Profile

  Send To Friend  |    Stumble It!  |    Digg It!  | 



Please add your comment below.
If you are registered, you can login and post under your registered name. If not, you can post as a guest or register.

* Please note that 411 moderates all comments. Your comment will show up on the site after it has been approved by an editor.
 
Name : 
Comment : 
Remaining Characters : 
2800
 

Comments (18)

 
Not to mention that cover art is goofy as hell.

Posted By: Wisecracker (Guest)  on April 05, 2010 at 11:17 PM

 
 
I could not disagree with you stronger... this album is really good... at LEAST a 8.0 on the scale of greatness... my standout tracks are the one with Lemmy, the ones with the dude from Alterbridge, and especially the one with Ian Astbury and Izzy(just a great track IMO)... as much as I hate to say this, even Fergie's track is good (and the girl CAN sing rock... look on youtube for her and Slash live, as well as her awesome performance with Mick Jagger at the R'N'R HOF concert from HBO)

Posted By: Stone2k (Guest)  on April 06, 2010 at 01:57 AM

 
 
Aaron Titan: Lost In Contradictions

It just doesn’t work and comes off pretty annoying......

...though I can see a lot of fans liking this song for whatever reason.

While cool and interesting collaborations in theory, just don’t work.............

...end up sounding like anything else on rock radio, which is where this album will undoubtedly find some decent success.

I can honestly say that I was pumped after seeing the tracklisting and who was on each song......

.....but it would’ve meant much more like, at least ten years ago when Ozzy hadn’t lost all the cred and respect he had left.


Posted By: Hoodoo91 (Guest)  on April 06, 2010 at 06:56 AM

 
 
I haven't heard the entire thing yet but the tracks I have heard we're quite good. Ozzy sounds like Ozzy and Slash sounds much more like his old G'n'R than he has in quite some time.

Posted By: guest-I-guess (Guest)  on April 06, 2010 at 07:26 AM

 
 
Hey - i appreciate your 'legend' icon so I can see your gradescale, but how about another icon where it directs us to see what albums you consider '10s'.

Posted By: Clash of Aaron Titan (Guest)  on April 06, 2010 at 09:24 AM

 
 
Completely disagree. I would give it an 8.0 easy. It has a nice mix of different styles and features something for everyone. How can you not like Fergie's song? It was MADE for her and it is one of the standouts of the album. The song with M. Shadows is great and I love it how Slash adopted a different style, playing more like metalcore guys than himself. It goes to show that he is versatile and can compete with the new batch of guitarists. I bought the UK edition with 17 tracks and I can honestly say I like 11 of them....11 out of 17? That is a winner!

Posted By: Armando Rodriguez (Registered)  on April 06, 2010 at 10:24 AM

 
 
Oh, and tell me this song is NOT for Axl Rose:

The fire started long ago
The flames burned out, still embers glow
So charred and black
There's nothing left to burn, to burn

We had the same dream
Lived life to extreme
A loaded gun jammed by a rose
The thorns are not around your head
Your ego cursed you till you bled
You cannot crucify the dead
To me you're dead, yeah

The future is unset in stone
Decisions past leave you alone
Betrayed us all with your own selfish greed, your greed, yeah
New soldiers now say
That your beggars collect
Re-crucified and paid by you
The thorns are not around your head
Your ego cursed you till you bled
You cannot crucify the dead
To me you're dead, yeah

We were like brothers with the world in our hands
You always have too much to say
Someday you look back and you wonder why
You let it all slip away, yeah

Crucify the dead
Crucify the dead

The thorns are not around your head
Your ego cursed you till you bled
You cannot crucify the dead
To me you're dead, yeah


Posted By: Armando Rodriguez (Registered)  on April 06, 2010 at 11:13 AM

 
 
I kind of agree with your assessment that the album is a little underwhelming. I don't think I disliked it as much as you did though. Slash's playing is amazing on most tracks, and I thought the Cornell song was HOT! And I enjoyed M. Shadows' cut as well, but overall, I was not really all that blown away.

Posted By: Guest#1930 (Guest)  on April 06, 2010 at 11:19 AM

 
 
I'm curious...is the album named "Slash" or is it "R&FN'R"? The album cover would suggest the latter.

Posted By: Guest#3914 (Guest)  on April 06, 2010 at 01:02 PM

 
 
The scale for review scores is one we all use on 411Mania, so it would be a collective list is Mitch or someone ever assembled one. I've personally not given an album a 10 since I started writing here last August; still waiting on that next "Sgt. Pepper's." Loved your guest screen name by the way!

@HooDoo91: Definitely lost in contradictions! Wasn't that a point I kind of made though? I wanted to like this and am a fan of most of the involved parties, but I just didn't dig it as a cohesive album.


Posted By: Aaron Titan (Registered)  on April 06, 2010 at 01:08 PM

 
 
Wow, I couldn't disagree more.. This CD greatly exceeded my expectations.. I don't regret spending a dime on it.. Ghost, By The Sword, Promise, Back To Cali.. Those are just a few of the songs that are kicking my butt!!

Posted By: Tbag (Guest)  on April 06, 2010 at 02:39 PM

 
 
This album kicks arse!!

Posted By: Tom (Guest)  on April 06, 2010 at 02:44 PM

 
 
Dude, you're way off the mark on this one. I actually expected this thing to be a piece of crap with a couple of tracks that would be outstanding due to Slash's greatness and the inevetibility factor. Couldn't have been more surprised. The only thing on there that sucked from my perspective was indeed the Oz cut.

8.5

Man, frickin' Stockdale does still kick major ass, eh?


Posted By: Guest#3694 (Guest)  on April 10, 2010 at 02:26 AM

 
 
From what i've heard i'm giving it a 8.5, thankfully I always take reviews with a grain of salt otherwise i'll never buy music.

Posted By: Guest#9032 (Guest)  on April 12, 2010 at 02:44 AM

 
 
I only FF thru " saint is a sinner". Every other song is great. The choices made for vocalists were well made. The tunes with Myles Kennedy ( who will be the touring vocalist) are my fave followed by any other in random order.
I have played this disc thru about 5-6 times and have no intention of letting up.


Posted By: Killer!!! (Guest)  on April 13, 2010 at 06:39 PM

 
 
Wow. Honestly, when I first heard about a Slash solo album, I was expecting it to sound the way this review covers it. And on first listen, it was okay. But after two listens, I'm pretty impressed. I mean, I can see 90% of these as singles, which is rare for ANY album. And really, Slash is a hard rock POP artist. He jams as hard as anybody but everything is CATCHY and not just some scorching riff that's un-hummable. Personally, I give this an 8, like most of the commenters.

Posted By: Matt (Guest)  on April 15, 2010 at 05:57 PM

 
 
its A7X not AX7...

Posted By: Jacob Boden (Guest)  on April 22, 2010 at 08:55 AM

 
 
Sorry but I have to disagree I love this album at first I thought it was quite mediocre but now I like pretty much every track, although I do agree that Nothing to Say sounds like Synester Gates

Posted By: hjfleeds (Guest)  on October 09, 2010 at 11:18 AM

 


www.41mania.com
Copyright � 2011 411mania.com, LLC. All rights reserved.
Click here for our privacy policy. Please help us serve you better, fill out our survey.
Use of this site signifies your agreement to our terms of use.