McCain Calls On Supporters To Be Respectful Of Obama, Gets Booed
Posted by Ashish on 10.10.2008
Says Obama is a decent person and not someone to be scared of...
Wow, talk about a 180. After a few days of wild crowds at his events, including people who yelled out racial slurs, and a week of attacks aimed at linking Obama to terrorism, McCain told his supporters at a Minnesota rally today to be respectful of Obama.
"I want everyone to be respectful. And let's make sure we are, because that's the way politics is done in America."
When a supporter told McCain that he's scared of an Obama Presidency, McCain said the following.
"I have to tell you, he is a decent person, a person that you do not have to be scared [of] as president of the United States."
The crowd booed, and some yelled "Come On, John" after McCain said this. But wait, there is more.
A woman at the town hall asks softly: "I've heard that Sen. Obama is an Arab."
McCain quickly cuts the woman off.
"No, maam. He's a decent family man and citizen," McCain says. "He's not. Thank you."
Now, first the obvious, good for John McCain. I'm happy that he is trying to put out this fire, because regardless of what side you're on, I don't think anyone (well, among the sane) wants to see this election turn to violence, rioting, etc.
But, this begs the question, is McCain in control of his own campaign anymore? Has it come to this? McCain can't even say a halfway decent thing about Obama without his crowd booing? He can't point out the truth -- that Obama is not an Arab -- without his crowd booing? Obama praises McCain's service in EVERY SPEECH HE GIVES and the crowd cheers. This has gone too far, and McCain now knows it.
McCain's campaign, for the past week, has tried to tie Obama to terrorists and Sarah Palin said Obama "pals around with terrorists." How can Obama "pal around with terrorists" and still be a decent person who America doesn't have to be scared of as President? The whole point of these "Obama is friends with terrorists" attacks are to make people scared of Obama, right? And now McCain says he is a decent person and nobody to be scared of? Huh? Who has been planting the idea in people's minds that Obama is a terrorist, or a friend of terrorists, or "scary," or whatever else? McCain essentially has admitted that his campaign's attacks over the past week were fake outrage over a story he knew was bogus. If he really thought Obama was tied to terrorism, he wouldn't call Obama a decent person and wouldn't tell his supporters that they have nothing to be scared of if Obama becomes President.
So can we assume those attacks will now stop? Is this just a public statement by McCain to get the media off his back or does he mean this, meaning he will stop the ridiculous low road attacks of the past week which, by design, were aimed at making people think Obama is tied to terrorism and therefore scare people of him? It's one or the other. McCain can't have it both ways. I'm glad he took this first step, but unless he goes all the way, all this amounts to is telling his supporters to do one thing while winking at them to do another. You can't call someone a "pal of terrorists" in post-9/11 America and not expect some people to get scared of that person being President and react in potentially extreme ways. If McCain says Obama is decent and nobody to be scared of, he is also saying that his attacks of the past week were exaggerated for political gain, because the two don't add up. You can't be both. McCain says one thing and his campaign says something totally different. McCain has never made any of these terrorist claims to Obama's face, and is now saying Obama is a decent family man who is nobody to be scared of as President. So, does McCain believe his campaign's own attacks against Obama as being a friend of terrorism? Obviously not.
Even FOX News spent a lot of time this afternoon talking about how McCain is now at odds with his own campaign, as his own campaign pursues personal attacks while McCain is now spending time at his own rallies defending Obama and essentially undoing what his own attack ads are trying to do. It's hard to make the case that people should be scared of an Obama Presidency, which is the goal of McCain's TV ads, when McCain himself says people have no reason to fear an Obama Presidency. However you want to slice this, McCain's campaign is obviously confused as to what they want to do.
People will see a lot of different things in this. Some will see this as a ploy where McCain says one thing while his campaign continues to do another. Some will say that this is a response to McCain's unfavorables skyrocketing since he started these negative attacks. Some will see it as campaign strategy shift #406 for the McCain campaign where he really does stop the low road attacks. Some will see it as McCain finally starting to see the type of people that make up a significant portion of his support and not liking it. Some will say that the Secret Service may have gotten involved. And some will say that McCain, knowing he is unlikely to win this election now, wants to help avoid any radical behavior towards Obama while also trying to repair his damaged reputation. Whatever it is you see here, one thing is for sure, defending Obama from his own campaign's attacks 25 days before the election isn't exactly the sign of a well run campaign.
Here are videos of the McCain rally where the above comments were made.
John's probably started saying this seeing that Obama and Biden called him out on not saying it to Obama's face. That and I really don't think John has much say in his own campaign.
Posted By: Johu Momar (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 06:44 PM
He's officially NUTS. He should go into retirement after he lose to never be seen again. EVER!.
Posted By: LawrenceNY (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 06:48 PM
Typical liberal Ashish. McCain has not changed his strategy 406 times.
It was 403 times. Stupid liberal website.
:-)
Posted By: MattL (Registered) on October 10, 2008 at 06:50 PM
However much I want him to lose, this is still the right thing to do, and show that the elevated level of respect I had for him amongst Republicans prior to this campaign wasn't misplaced.
HOWEVER
A woman at the town hall asks softly: "I've heard that Sen. Obama is an Arab."
McCain quickly cuts the woman off.
"No, maam. He's a decent family man and citizen," McCain says. "He's not. Thank you."
Are to extract from this that Arabs are automatically neither decent family men nor citizens?
Posted By: Pete Thorn (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 06:58 PM
I'm voting for Obama, but good for McCain.
Posted By: The Great Capt. Smooth (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 07:06 PM
This just makes me wonder who in the fuck these people are at this point. Even the self-avowed conservatives I know personally have some sense that Obama doesn't represent their own ideologies, but that it's a POLITICAL ISSUE of opinion and belief and not some archaic tabloid-style conspiracy theory about Arabs in the goddamned Oval Office.
Objection to Obama on principle is one thing. Dusting off modern-day McCarthyism because your candidate can't get his shit together and then TURNING ON HIM when he tries to be objective is far more terrifying than a black man being elected as the president of the United States.
Posted By: Meirsch (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 07:13 PM
I have desparately been searching for a copy of this video since I saw it on CNN ten minutes ago. Thank you, Ashish.
Maybe it will help if McCain reins in his pit bull, Palin.
Posted By: kimmg (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 07:22 PM
I'm just worried that the genie is out of the bottle at this point.
In the month of October, we've had stories of people with Obama shirts being refused service, epithets screamed at them in public, and one poor bastard was actually shot three times.
Not to be a Cynnical Cyrus here, but I really hope the psychopaths that populate McCain/Palin rallys these days don't try anything. We're too close to making history (and he's the best candidate too: Bonus!) for a repeat of this nation's shameful history when it comes to progressive movers and shakers.
But Ashish? I give McCain NOTHING. He and Sarah Talking-Point stoked these fires, and he said nothing until he absolutely had to. God forbid anything does happen to Obama in the last 25 days, it rests on the collective heads of the John McCain presidential campaign.
Posted By: Jevan (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 07:50 PM
If you need any further proof that much of what remains of the so-called conservative based is fully of yokels and ignoramuses. that video pretty much provides it. Whether McCain is doing it because he has rediscovered what little remains of his honor, or because he himself is becoming frightened of what he has unleashed, the fact remains that there are a lot of very stupid Americans out there. And I mean VERY VERY STUPID Americans out there. People like that, who boo the candidate for daring to say something nice about the opposing candidate do not deserve the right to vote. I'm beginning to wonder if literacy tests might not be a bad thing after all--or at the very least some type of citizenship test similar to what immigrants have to take when becoming a citizen.
I've said it before and I'll say it again, you can never go broke betting on how dumb, paranoid and self-serving the American public can get. Hell it took 7 years of what has to be the worst presidency in a lifetime, plus the worst economic disaster in many lifetimes to give Obama even a chance. Let's hope that all of this fades and that decency and goodness actually work.
BTW, I would love to see Obama thank McCain for his comments at the last debate, and then tell him that if he has any honor left, to tell his people to KNOCK IT OFF.
Posted By: Michael L (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 07:52 PM
When I learned that McCain was the Republican nominee I was actually relieved. I'm pretty much a Democrat, but I like McCain. Sure, he's got his slimeball moments like all politicians, but he seems like a way, waaaaay more decent person than someone like, say, George W. Bush, or that worthless, heartless, waste of flesh Karl Rove.
Plus, when I hear McCain talk on TV, I don't have a problem with him, even when it's something I don't happen to agree with. Bush's voice aggravates the hell out of me and makes me want to punch him in the face. Does anyone else ever get that feeling?
Cue the hilarious "I'd like to punch YOU in the face, Zing!" comments.
Posted By: Zingy (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 08:41 PM
Translation: I'm too old for this shit vote for the other guy
Posted By: The Rev (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 08:41 PM
Nice to know he reads my stuff.
Posted By: J.D. Dunn (Registered) on October 10, 2008 at 08:42 PM
This is the problem with small-town America, it's completely isolated from the REAL WORLD, rationale, and tolerance. And for John McCain for saying he's not Arab, rather a decent family man, just shows the level of racism that still exists in America.
Posted By: Guest#6068 (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 08:45 PM
Stay classy, Republicans!
Seriously though, these are by far the worst possible republicans to be seen on national TV. Racist, intolerant, moronic. It really isn't helping McCain that all of his televised supporters act like morons.
Posted By: Drew Robbins (Registered) on October 10, 2008 at 08:52 PM
RE: Pete Thorn
On other accounts of this exchange that I have read, the lady who asks the question appears to say "Arab terrorist," hence McCain's response. Don't know if that's accurate or not, since I haven't seen video of it, but that's what I've read on other sites.
Posted By: DaiMonPaul (Registered) on October 10, 2008 at 09:05 PM
Well, if McCain's idea is to catch us off guard by suddenly running an honorable campaign, it's working.
I mean it's working on me, anyway.
Posted By: Vallejo (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 09:43 PM
It's kind of sad that we've reached a point where we're applauding John for simply saying things that are true. I guess he realized that he can't win, so he may as well try and salvage some semblance of his ever withering credibility.
Posted By: Michael O (Registered) on October 10, 2008 at 10:11 PM
JD:
Haha, when I read your piece today, all I could think was that I wish there was some way McCain could be reading it too.
Posted By: Michael O (Registered) on October 10, 2008 at 10:13 PM
Michael L, you state how wrong it is for some people to call democrats naughty names, but yet in the same entry, you manage to insult others (no doubt conservatives) by calling them bad names.
You, sir, are the epitome of hypocrisy and should learn to either walk the walk or simply shut up.
Posted By: Mikel (Registered) on October 10, 2008 at 10:27 PM
If McCain had behaved this way to begin with, maybe I wouldn't have lost all the respect I had for him.
It's too late, too little.
I wouldn't have voted for him in the first place, but I would've still had my respect for him.
Posted By: Lawrence (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 10:37 PM
After the latest debacle, I truly, sincerely hope that REAL Republicans stand up and say "I'm as mad as hell, and I'm not going to take this anymore" and vote Obama.
For too long good, honest Republicans have been pushed aside and forced to let guys like Hannity and Limbaugh be their speakers. Republicans need to take back their party and the first thing they can do is vote Obama and show McCain and the Bush Neo-Cons that they aren't going to let their party be ran this way.
Republicans have talking points on issues, but you'd never know it. I urge all my Republican friends to vote Obama so that you can show your party you won't stand for these kinds of tactics anymore.
In 2012 a real Republican can run. Let's bury McCain and the demoralizing Bush legacy of smear politics.
Stand up and shout, "I'm as mad as hell, and I'm not going to take this anymore!"
Posted By: Poppycock (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 10:56 PM
There are some radicals out there. They are doing what they feel is right to them. The terrible thing about it is that they are judging him because of his differences. Why can't people just focus on the similarities?
Posted By: John (Guest) on October 10, 2008 at 11:27 PM
Hmm so McCain is saying arabs can't be decent people...
Posted By: poffo316 (Guest) on October 11, 2008 at 01:14 AM
Hmm so McCain is saying arabs can't be decent people...
Posted By: poffo316 (Guest) on October 11, 2008 at 01:14 AM
think ya missed the point
Posted By: Guest#8336 (Guest) on October 11, 2008 at 02:45 AM
This race has become so negative and we the people seem to agree with our side even though in our heart we know that they are wrong. It's time to open our eye's and use our heart to see the truth. if you HATE any of the two people running for president you have a problem. Because they may be our leader one day.
Posted By: Kenneth (Guest) on October 12, 2008 at 04:17 AM