// Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.'s Most Formidable Foe Isn't Hydra; It's Arrow
// Robert Plant Says Led Zeppelin Will Never Perform Again Together
// DDP Says He Was Set Up By Nancy Grace
// Chuck Liddell Needs to Get Over How Chael Sonnen Promotes Fights
// 8–Minute Multiplayer Walk Through For Watch Dogs


411mania RSS Feeds

Follow 411mania on Twitter!

Add 411 On Facebook

411mania » The 411 » Jeremy Thomas
Name:Jeremy Thomas
Current Roles:Film and DVD Reviewer, The Hush-Hush News Report, The Movie Zone Roundtable, The 4 R's of Raw & SmackDown, Wrestling Fact or Fiction, TNA Monthly Roundtable and Wrestler of the Week Organizer
Past Roles:Multi-Time Participant in Movies and Wrestling Fact or Fiction; Guest Host for 411 Movie Fact or Fiction for August 2008
Other credits:Contributer to the Monthly Movie Roundtable, WWE PPV Roundtables, the Movie & Wrestling Zone Top 5's, and The Watcher Chronicles and Angel Investigated
Quote:"Yeah. That makes sense."
History:Written by the victors
Movie Review: A Nightmare on Elm Street - 05.05.2010

When I was at work the day after I saw A Nightmare on Elm Street, one of my co-workers asked me how it was. My response was that it looked kinda like a duck, and it quacked like a duck (if that duck's amp was set to 11), but it was no freakin' duck.

What I mean by that is that this is a film that does exactly what Platinum Dunes does best. They can copy the form of a film, and they can throw in a whole crap load of jump scares to appeal to the modern horror crowd, but they don't know how to take a film and remake it into something scary and worthwhile.

We talked last week--and for years, really--about Platinum Dunes' legacy with horror remakes. They've remade The Texas Chainsaw Massacre and a sequel, The Amityville Horror, The Hitcher and Friday the 13th, and produced the original horror films The Unborn and the straight-to-video Horsemen. Outside of Amityville, none of them have been worth their salt and they've all followed the same formulaic problems.

You see that here with Elm Street. They know the story, they know what scenes in the original film are most well-received, and they know what elements made it work so well. But somehow, they are unable to translate the experience to the new film. I think that part of this is because the film has two separate goals. The first is to satisfy fans of the original by including elements they loved, and the second is to take it in a new direction.

The problem is that the original elements they included don't really work that well, and the new direction they took didn't work either. And that's sad because there was a lot of potential in the early moments and even in some of the later stuff, but it just doesn't translate as a whole.

Part of the problem is in the casting of the lead. Rooney Mara plays Nancy, and my immediate impression was that the casting director wanted Emily Blunt but couldn't get her because she was too old. Mara seems like Blunt's younger clone with about half the personality. She seems just bored throughout much of it.

I did enjoy some of the other kids, and they seemed to have it better including Thomas Dekker as Jesse and Katie Cassidy as Kris. Jackie Earle Haley plays Freddy of course, and he does what he can but he's working under more prohibitive make-up and more voice modulation than Robert Englund was.

Then, there's the back story. There was no need for this, and while I see what they were getting at it just doesn't work. The reason it doesn't work is because of all the plot holes. I have an list here of things that occurred to me.

Why do the parents erase all possible history of the kids going to school together, but Nancy's mother keep that photo with ALL the required evidence Nancy and Glen need?

How do the parents manage to get the preschool shut down after they kill Freddy and tell everyone he just ran away?

Why are the kids so god damned stupid? I mean, when Glen and Nancy stop off so Glen can get his anti-ADHD medication--which is something I enjoyed--why did Nancy decide to stay in the car? Seriously, I get that people are stupid in horror movies, but that's new levels of dumb.

Why do we need to have an entire subplot based on whether Freddy is innocent or not when we all know that he's not, and that ultimately this is just going to make the kids look that much stupider for going out into the middle of nowhere so they can be alone?

Now, like I said there's things I enjoyed. The opening murder was nicely done and I appreciated Freddy being creative and hiding his kill there as a suicide. I also very much liked the scene with Freddy and Nancy in the dream zone at the school. It was creepy in a very skeevy kind of way, but I didn't think it went over the top. But the rest of it is bathed in stupidity and a lack of creativity and I just didn't buy into it.

Final Rating: 2.5 out of 10
full blog
Chris Brown's Washington, DC Assault Trial to Be Delayed Until June (04.23.2014)
It could take as long as a year to get started...
DDP Says He Was Set Up By Nancy Grace (04.23.2014)
He wanted to leave as soon as it started...
Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.'s Most Formidable Foe Isn't Hydra; It's Arrow (04.23.2014)
Why Marvel is finding itself coming up second-best in the TV game...
Triple H Graces WWE Payback Poster (04.23.2014)
With Sledgie in hand...
Batista Says He Doesn't Get Fans Who Confuse 'Show' From 'Reality' (04.23.2014)
He has some words for his critics...
Hulk Hogan May Go Mercenary For The Expendables 4 (04.23.2014)
A new rumor puts him in the next film...
Hulk Hogan May Go Mercenary For The Expendables 4 (04.23.2014)
A new rumor puts him in the next film...
Producer Gary Goddard Denies Abuse Allegations By Bryan Singer's Accuser (04.23.2014)
Goddard's lawyer says it's "fantastical"...
Watch: Beck Covers Arcade Fire at Coachella (04.23.2014)
Beck takes on "Rebellion (Lies)"...
Slipknot Bassist's Widow Slams Bandmates in Court For Not Helping Save Him (04.23.2014)
Paul Gray's wife says no one cared...
Robert Plant Says Led Zeppelin Will Never Perform Again Together (04.23.2014)
The chances are zero...
Pharrell Williams Spends Ninth Week on Top of Billboard Hot 100 (04.23.2014)
The singles chart is "Happy" as ever...
Anton Yelchin, Zooey Deschanel, John Hawkes Set For Dark Comedy The Driftless Area (04.23.2014)
Plus Ciaran Hinds and more...
Mattell and Sony Gearing Up For Live-Action Barbie Film (04.23.2014)
Another toy line being tapped for a franchise...
Johnny Depp's Mortdecai Set For Release Early Next Year (04.23.2014)
An action-comedy involving espionage and Nazi gold...
Director of Previous Fantastic Four Films Talks About What He Learned From Them (04.23.2014)
Tim Story says he learned a lot...
Bellator Finalizes Card for Bellator 120 (04.23.2014)
The full card for the debut PPV is set...
Stephen Colbert Discusses Churches Using MMA To Increase Attendance (04.23.2014)
Colbert has some fun with Fight Church...
50 Cent Returns to His Roots With 'Hustler' Music Video (04.22.2014)
Check out Fiddy's latest track...
WWE News: Latest Plans For Shield and Wyatts, Austin Talks Same-Sex Marriage (04.22.2014)
Will the Wyatts turn face soon?
full archive

Copyright (c) 2011 411mania.com, LLC. All rights reserved.
Click here for our privacy policy. Please help us serve you better, fill out our survey.
Use of this site signifies your agreement to our terms of use.